Association of American Colleges and Universities On Campus With Women About Us
Contact Us
Campus Women Lead

Fall 2008

Volume 37
Number 2

Rethinking Scientific Pedagogies


Director's Outlook

From Where I Sit

Featured Topic

In Brief

Campus Women Lead

Global Perspectives

Data Connection



For Your Bookshelf

About This Issue

Rethinking Scientific Pedagogies

Collin County Community College
Collin County Community College

Twenty-five years ago, Sally Ride, a graduate of Stanford University with degrees in both physics and English, led American women to new heights when she ascended into space on the shuttle Challenger. The echoes of NASA’s shattering glass ceiling have reverberated ever since. In the same year, Barbara McClintock (with less fanfare but no small import) received the Nobel Prize for her groundbreaking work on maize chromosomes—research that has similarly reverberated in fields from medicine to botany. Yet in 2008, these women’s legacies, although well-heralded, remain only partially fulfilled. As Judy Touchton reports in her forthcoming monograph, A Measure of Equity: Women’s Progress in Higher Education, the latest data indicate that women have far to travel in fields such as physics, where women earned less than one-third of the PhDs awarded in 2006. Moreover, despite the honor bestowed on McClintock, women have received only twelve Nobel Prizes in scientific fields since the award’s inception in 1901. Thus while Ride and McClintock symbolize undeniable change within scientific fields, one still hears the question Virginia Valian raised in her 1998 book echoing in labs and classrooms throughout America: “Why so slow?”

Nearly a decade into the twenty-first century, the answer to Valian’s question remains elusive. Nevertheless, the fields in which women are succeeding suggest some possible clues. Women’s participation in biology and psychology is far above parity, and conventional wisdom might suggest that these fields, along with “feminine” (or feminized) professions like nursing, have simply been considered more suitable choices for women. Yet the possibility remains that these “helping professions” merely offer clearer opportunities for women—and men—to enact social change, and are thus more attractive to students. If that is the case, the question arises: what if all professions were seen as “helping professions,” with classroom pedagogies leading students to see the practical applications embedded in scientific inquiry? What if science education routinely raised questions embedded at the core of liberal education?

The authors of this issue of On Campus with Women are applying these questions to their research and teaching with promising results. While Sue Rosser explores new technologies to engage underrepresented students, including women, in the civic side of engineering, the faculty of the Kate Gleason College of Engineering at Rochester Institute of Technology finds that creating a civic culture through mentoring and outreach activities yields greater engagement and retention for young women. Lorelle Espinosa reinforces the need for inclusive pedagogies, including feminist pedagogies, that improve climates for women of color, and Elise Niedermeier explains how similar classroom approaches broadened her horizons as a non-science major. Beyond the undergraduate degree, Pat Lowrie examines the power of inclusive leadership in the sciences, while Judy Touchton asks how women are doing once they enter the science workforce. In aggregate, this issue’s authors illustrate not only the continued need for improved science climates, but the power of new science pedagogies to effect these ends.

Just as Sally Ride’s journey from physics student to astronaut symbolizes what is possible for women despite the challenges that remain, her academic background in science and humanities gestures toward the promise of a balanced educational foundation. Scientific inquiry that incorporates aspects of feminist pedagogy and liberal education will benefit more than the students it engages—it will enhance the world they will help to shape, whether through Nobel-prize-winning inquiry or through applied scientific understanding on a more personal scale.

"The challenge for engineering to identify specific interventions that can successfully nurture hands-on, socially relevant disciplinary engagement early in the curricular sequence." 

Sue V. Rosser


In this issue, Sue V. Rosser describes a new project at Georgia Tech designed to retain more women and students of color in engineering, and faculty members at Rochester Institute of Technology share a comprehensive program for women based on community outreach and mentoring. Read more


This issue's Global Perspective highlights the historical context and continuing challenges for women's education in the Solomon Islands.

Read more

A Measure of Equity: Women's Progress in Higher Education by Judy Touchton

A Measure of Equity

Women have made considerable advances in higher education over the past several decades, yet the journey toward full equity is not yet complete. A Measure of Equity: Women’s Progress in Higher Education presents a comprehensive overview of data, marks areas of progress, and identifies action items that would advance gender equity in colleges and universities. The research examines women’s access to college, areas of study in undergraduate and post-graduate work, status as faculty, and leadership as administrators and presidents.


Home | About OCWW | Contact Us | Archives
Copyright © 2018 Association of American Colleges and Universities
On Campus With Women All Rights Reserved.